Give the gift of GRIT to your child this year on Independence Day.
For our generation it is an accepted socio-cultural norm to live one’s lives on other people’s terms and expectations of us, primarily our parents. Many of us continue to perpetuate this because it’s the only worldview we have been taught. However, we all quite understand that our children, most of them millennials, are growing up in a world that is encountering paradigms significantly different than ours. New career options, new technologies, new ways of communication. Its a whole new world order reflected in news media, sci-fi movies and popular television serials like Stranger Things, Orphan Black, Sense8 etc. A world with a perspective that we cannot possibly prepare our children for with our own set of knowledge and skills. What we can instead do is work on the third aspect of this holy trinity of survival kit – attitude.
This Independence Day, let us offer the gift of GRIT to our children. Falling, as you know by now, is not the issue. We fell. They will fall too. It is the attitude of rising from falls that needs passion and perseverance. A combination of these two attitudes make what we now understand as Grit.
Psychologist Angela Duckworth, recipient of the prestigious MacArthur Fellowship, also known as the “Genius Grant”, in her book, Grit: The power of passion and perseverance (and her immensely popular Ted Talk) explains why Grit is important and what is its correlation with success.
Grit, gives us the motivation to achieve our objectives through persistent effort. It is essential to accomplish anything of significance. It is also one big factor that makes your child independent of circumstances that s/he encounters throughout life. Grit is something that can be nurtured and grown within oneself. It’s that lifelong gift which becomes the source of power with consistent use.
We don’t always get to see anything beyond the end result. Both, of failure and success. For most struggles are endured alone or behind closed doors and not shared. Think of it, how often have our parents discussed their struggles with us? If they have discussed the difficulties or struggles, did they also share along the way which strategies were used? Which ones failed and which ones were useful and why? What kind of energy and effort was needed to come out of it? Where did they muster that Grit from? Which matters they persevered and which ones they gave up and why? What about you? How often do you share your challenges and your strategies to overcome them with your growing and even grown up children? Or with your spouse ? Most of the time, the struggles and the strategies are in one’s mind and heart. Are you ‘giving up’ or ‘holding up’ – using your attitude of Grit.
How does one harness Grit? What does it entail? How can you possibly “gift” Grit when it is so intrinsic whilst gift implies something completely extrinsic. That is where the significance of parenting comes in.
Parenting is a verb. It is a role performed. It can be for your biological child, for your adopted child, for your neighbour or relative’s child, for your student and so on. Any adult who interacts with a child performs some aspect of the parenting role. For those of us who do that on a daily basis, here are a few pointers to gifting our children with Grit.
Passion: the first half of Grit
How does one define it? How does one find it? One thing must be clear, passion is to be understood not in the granularity but in the big picture. It can’t just be temporary excitement. Nor does it have to be a thing that you love every component of. It’s a combination of deep interest and meaning.
How do you live it and share it with your child?
-If you are into sports, share with your child the passion of your sport and the fact that you may not like the fact of getting up 5 am in the morning to practice or prepare your body. But you do it for you like the big picture of what sports means for you.
-If you are a teacher, share with your child your passion and satisfaction you get of sharing knowledge and mentoring young minds. Also share the fact that you may not like doing some of the drudgery that comes along with it, like filling up lesson plans or administrative documentation, assessments or difficult parent teacher meetings. Yet the impact your teaching has on young minds, helping shape lives – is what you look forward to.
-If you are into music, share with your child the passion you have and what music means to you. Share the tedious practice you underwent or are still undergoing over several years. That oftentimes you were possibly at the brink of giving up but continued nevertheless as you had the eye on the big picture.
You can draw this out for any profession/entrepreneurship. Each of it has a big portion that can come under drudgery or routine or preparation, which comes attached for completing the big picture.
Amitabh Bachchan, the iconic actor comes to my mind as an epitome of the combination of passion and perseverance – Grit! His journey from voice narrator in Mrinal Sen’s Bhuvan Shome to supporting actor in Anand and angry young man in Zanjeer to the iconic Deewar. Sholay released on 15th August, 1975 and the rest is history. Or is it? We know the successful ones and we also know that most of his early films did very badly. Fatal injury and recovery during shooting of Coolie in Bangalore. The Bofors scandal followed by financial crisis, ABCL debacle to the point where his home nearly got auctioned. He went on to working on his comeback and how! From what became the household lexicon of “lock kar diya jaye?” in KBC TV series and many a Film awards and honorary doctorates, books, temples and memorials later to the current celluloid success of Paa, Piku and Pink.
Perseverance: the second half of Grit
When reality falls short of expectations. Many of us give up because we don’t fully realize what it takes. The mind set of perseverance is about seeing failure differently. How to use failure as a tool rather than a hindrance? How does one be honest with self and consider the pain of defeat before accepting that it’s worth enduring towards the goal one has set out to achieve.
How do you live it and share it with your child?
The story of the Three little Pigs is read out to all children at some point in time of growing up, in school or at home. Hard work pays off – is a well-known adage that is sermonised ever so often in parenting and teaching. For a good reason! It surely must have been difficult for the third pig to persevere even after his other brothers built their homes of straw and sticks with very little time and effort, isn’t it? The third pig however knew it was worth enduring all the hassle and drudgery for the matter of long term safety. All the brothers did have the knowledge that there was a big-bad wolf out there. They all had the skill to bring a strong house. Whereas only the third pig had the Attitude.
Grit is an attitude which can be acquired and honed. Continue to build yours along with your child and find success in your parenting goals. We all have our own ideas of success, and the word itself isn’t worth generalising. To me, it correlates with time invested.
Meaningful success takes a long time, and the longer it takes, the more opportunities arise for failure and disinterest. Grit plays the role of the discipline of a recurring deposit or systemic investment plan – if you will, for long term gains. Of course, time alone doesn’t drive progress. Feedback, along with deliberate and effective practice, are needed, too.
Benjamin Jones and Bruce Weinberg published a paper, Age dynamics in scientific creativity, in which they analyzed 525 Nobel prizes awarded between 1900 and 2008. The study was to see if there was a link between age and when important discoveries were made. They found that with a few exceptions, all winners produced their greatest work well past the age of 30.
It’s easy to say you need passion and perseverance to succeed, but it’s also important to know what these two entail. If your child is young, you have a high degree of control on your child. As the child grows, while your control decreases, your influence starts to show. If you want your child to show Grit in their attitude, start early by sharing your personal stories of Grit. Your efforts to come out of loss and grief. Of reinventing after job loss. Of getting out of your comfort zone and staying there until you were enjoying it. The pictures here give a glimpse into mine as I cycled through a high altitude terrain of Ladakh with a bunch of my teenage students. At the time I was 50year old with a fairly sedentary lifestyle.
So the next time you grit your teeth and continue with effective and involved parenting which by all means is tedious – know that you are showing Grit for the long term success of your child. All the best to us on living and gifting Grit. Do share your thoughts and stories of your Grit.
Happy Independence Day!

5 effective and time tested ideas for motivating your Child.
“You can steer yourself any direction you choose”. – Dr. Suess. His book Oh, the places You’ll go? has been one of the most popular choices as the graduation gift for the preschool children over the years. The intention is to reinforce the belief that children are naturally endowed with curiosity and the capability to work on their curiosity. Children believe that they can do everything! They always imagine what they want in great zest and detail. It is up to us as adults – both parents and teachers to not shake off that belief as we are the biggest influencers around them. A big responsibility that, isn’t it?
What drives children to do things that they should and stop what they shouldn’t? As adults, we know that how we respond to what is happening around us is always up to us. We are in control of our responses with the deeper understanding of the fact that whatever is happening around us, to us, with us, may not be under our control at all times. What we do is take control of our actions in a given situation. Once that is done, we can increase our circle of influence to situations or people around us. There would still remain a wider area, that would always be outside of our control but will influence our wellbeing. How can we instil that attitude of optimism and grit? How can we exemplify that to our children?
Kids have a strong sense of connection with parents and that is a very powerful tool for motivation. Studies have shown that children who feel secure in their attachment to their parents are more resilient. It is known now that character strengths like curiosity and self-control are teachable skills.
How shall we invest in their character? Here are 5 effective and time tested ideas for your consideration:
Here are a few suggestions to take your understanding further:
– great list of books to have in your child’s home library.
– check out this ted talk by Rita Pierson. She calls for educators to believe in their students and build connections with them
– a Tedx talk by Jennifer Nacif who tells parents exactly how to motivate your children, by changing your ways from manipulations to motivation.
For years it has been believed that cognitive capabilities are the key drivers of success. However, over the years, research has shown as has my experience of being an educator, that persistence and grit, self-control and optimism are some of the key qualities that help children succeed and remain happy. A strong and positive relationship with parents motivates the child to not only achieve but exceed their own capabilities.
Nivedita Mukerjee is a journalist, educator and parent. She writes about matters that concern a child’s success and well-being. She can be reached at niveditamukerjee10@gmail.com.
A version of this post is also published here:
https://www.parentcircle.com/article/5-proven-ideas-for-motivating-your-child/
Within their first couple of parent-teacher meetings the preschool teachers repeatedly hear the following concerns, with varying degrees of anxiousness :
“My child can’t sit still for 5 minutes!”
“My child day dreams randomly while doing something and sits at a task unfinished.”
“I can’t seem to get my child to finish even a simple puzzle.”
Does any of the above sound familiar to you?
Here are some ways that you can help your child concentrate better:
You would need to keep re-evaluating the suggestions mentioned and discuss the same with your child’s teacher to figure out what works for your child and in which situation. As your child grows, crossing various milestones in his/her preschool years, the needs and thus the techniques to enhance concentration, would change.
Games and activities that help building capability to concentrate in your child:
For pre-schoolers, there are several simple games and activities that you can engage in with your child at home, to help him/her focus on a given task while having loads of fun. A lot of them are variations of dot to dot activities that build up the attention span while improving the hand-eye coordination and teaching number, colour, pattern etc. Here are a few references for free printables :
http://www.education.com/worksheets/preschool/dot-to-dots/
http://www.preschool-printable-activities.com/dot-to-dot-printables.html
There are YouTube videos that guide you to make your own dot to dot activity sheet like this one:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5rb8Dynf0js
There are some memory games available online for kids like:
http://www.memozor.com/memory-game-online-free/for-kids
http://www.sproutonline.com/games
Many activity kits and board games for memory building for young children are available, for example :
http://www.activityvillage.co.uk/memory-games
http://littlebinsforlittlehands.com/10-best-preschool-board-games/
Amongst the concerns that parents of a pre-schooler may have on their child’s attention span, I have often heard parents wondering :
“Is it normal for my child to be bouncing up and down while watching TV?”
“ My child moves on to playing with another toy even as he has taken out something else to play with!”
“My child can’t hold a conversation or a line of thought.”
“Does my child have ADHD?”
While ADHD (Attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder) is one of the most common brain-based condition of childhood, all restless ness cannot be labelled as ADHD.
What is ADHD? Before you get worked up, here’s a link for you to know more:
http://www.webmd.com/add-adhd/guide/attention-deficit-hyperactivity-disorder-adhd#1
The children with ADHD may not:
The signs of ADHD also change over time. The struggles that a child suffering with ADHD in preschool will go through would be quite different in elementary, middle and high school. You may consider early intervention once you have observed your child carefully, discussed with the child’s teacher, consulted your child’s paediatrician and consulted the learning specialists or specialists like audiologist (for hearing issues), speech pathologist (for speech and language related issues), neurologist, behavioural paediatrician etc. Observe your child and make notes so that you can share the same with the teacher/s and specialists for better understanding.
As an educator, some activities that I have seen having positive influence on memory and focus are :
Each of the above help in the following ways:
Some of my all-time favourite outdoor games for pre-schoolers can be found here :
http://www.education.com/activity/preschool/outdoor/
You can try including these activities in your everyday routine:
This is an all-time favourite sensorial activity – kneading dough is fun, messy, works out the muscles of fingers and arms; following a recipe also helps your child to plan a sequence of actions and possibility to modify when repeated. Opportunities of creativity with different kinds of ingredients to add to cookies and/or stuffing the parathas, making variations to tweak them to their own and their family/friends suggestions and taste is very good for their emotional and cognitive capabilities. Both of these support development of executive function.
These require specific use of working memory. As you put in familiar objects, whether the child’s toys or everyday items that child is familiar with like cell phone, spectacle case, toffee etc. and ask the child to feel the objects from outside or by putting the hand inside the bag and guess what they are. It would need the child to use their sensory information of touch to imagine the shape and form of the object to recognise it.
Relationship of aerobic fitness and motor skills with memory and attention in pre-schoolers(Ballabeina): A cross-sectional and longitudinal study done by Iris Niederer, Susi Kriemler, Janine Gut, Tim Hartmann, Christial Schindler, Jerome Barral and Jardena Puder led to the conclusion that –
“…In young children, higher baseline aerobic fitness and motor skills were related to a better spatial working memory and/or attention at baseline, and to some extent also to their future improvements over the following 9 months.”
Here’s a link to their study.
https://bmcpediatr.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1471-2431-11-34
Based on their results, they have suggested that exercises involving specific mental processing, including executive functions like reasoning, problem solving, planning etc. which go on to help in managing time and paying attention – are most suitable to trigger overall cognitive development in young children. They further mention that their data contributes to the emerging field of brain fitness and highlight the importance of a promotion of physical education.
The link above will take you to a list of 8 key executive functions that your child needs in order to organise their time and work. Each of these may be strengthened using various strategies that would help your child organise and act on information received. You can help your child or take him/her to a specialist to learn ways to hone them or work around, if there are issues in this area.
To help your child with improving their working memory, you will find some very useful tips here:
http://learningworksforkids.com/2013/04/5-ways-to-maximize-attention-and-boost-memory/
Choice of appropriate diet is essential in helping your child focus:
High sugar foods set kids up for a mid-morning energy crash. Proteins and complex carbs, that take time to digest, make ideal breakfast combinations not only for adults, but more so for kids whose day might peak with literacy/numeracy – high cognition activity in the mid mornings. Options of oatmeal or upama, eggs and toast/French toast, rava idlis with grated vegetables, dal-dosas, dal and vegetable mixed parathas, nuts and berries, whole wheat bread and cheese or peanut butter and jelly, whole wheat crackers or tortillas with cheese, these coupled with unsweetened juice, chocolate milk, fruit salads with curd are good to keep your child going through the day without the sugar crash and feeling sluggish, lethargic, anxious and distracted.
Include your child in planning for his/her meals from the time you visit the grocery store. Have them help you pick up the fruits and vegetables they would like to be served up. It is a sensorial experience for them and they remember and enjoy their meals when they have picked it up themselves. The four nutritious groups you need to keep in mind to include in each of the meals would be:
The foods to be limited and/or avoided would be:
Fussy eaters under 5 year old, might need supplements containing Vitamins A and D. This can be done under advisement from your paediatrician.
A study, “Impact of iron supplementation on cognitive functions in preschool and school-aged children : the Indian experience” By Subadra Seshadri and Tara Gopaldas talks about the significance of managing iron levels for young children. Click here to read more.
http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/50/3/675.2.short
Finally, developing executive functions – attention, impulse control, working memory, planning – all are a combination of nature and nurture. And while it might be hard to change IQ, it is definitely possibly to improve a child’s ability to concentrate and increase executive functions. Do remember however, keeping on task longer should not be confused with compliance, obedience, sitting quietly or staying still etc. It has to be about children to persist to achieve the goal they have set for themselves and solve the problems to satisfy themselves and not for consequence of reward or punishment.
Nivedita Mukerjee is a journalist, educator and parent. She writes about matters that concern a child’s success and well-being. She can be reached at niveditamukerjee10@gmail.com.
This post has also been published by 6D news. Please find the link here : http://6dnews.com/boosting-concentration-memory-power-in-pre-schoolers/
A version of this post has also been published here:
https://www.parentcircle.com/article/boosting-concentration-and-memory-power-in-pre-schoolers/
As your child gets to his/her first ‘double digit’ milestone birthday – the big 10, something turns in the attitude of parenting in you. Have you noticed that? All that was cute and cuddly, now looks like a box tied up neatly with a bow of expectations. Of your own. Could be reminiscent of what your family expected from you. Or possibly some of what you expected of yourself. Add to this, what you aspire for your child. So much potential! Alongside these expectations from your child, you also create expectations from yourselves for a new wave of parenting that sweeps over you. Rightly so, for now, the existential nurturing needs that you fulfilled for your child is over taken by the child himself/herself. The child can pretty much take care of all his/her needs. From feeding, bathing to asking and negotiating. Both your and your child’s roles and responsibilities now need to go through an overhaul! Your parenting style needs to move from that of primarily nurturing and stimulating, to providing for wider exposure, higher challenges and connecting-communicating for a deeper relationship.
It is typically around the age of 10, when your child is most likely to be in grade 5, a new sense of independence dawns. Sometimes you will feel that your child is pushing you away. He/she tests the limits that have been set by you over the past years of growing up. What has happened is that your child is changing both physically and emotionally. This has led to significant development in the cognitive as well as social aspects of the child’s personality. The child is now demanding autonomy. Time for you to respect that. However, parental support, supervision, monitoring, tracking performance and growth in various areas assume even greater importance during these pre-adolescent years.
While your child is not a teen yet, he/she is out of his/her childhood. Remember:
What is it that most children exhibit during these wonderful years of growing out of childhood and becoming an adolescent teen? Over the years of being an educator, I have conducted several sessions on puberty and changes with this age group. Have taught and discussed with them content ranging from lake eutrophication and impact on ecosystem to classification in animal and plant kingdom. From Shakespeare – the bard and Steve Jobs the entrepreneur to Claude Monet – the impressionist. Have travelled with them for days on multiple school trips to a range of destinations, to study history, geography, sciences – all the while understanding each other. I must say, I have enjoyed and learned much about the behaviour of pre-adolescents during these long and intense interactions. What I am sharing below are general characteristics as observed and understood by me. Read this keeping in consideration the understanding that you have of your own child. His/her temperament, factors of home and family, friends in school and neighbourhood, tasks undertaken, maturity level and if there’s any ongoing factor of illness, changes, happenings like birth, death, adoption, marriage etc. – that could potentially put your child either in a state of flux or stability.
These three years are seen as the calm before storm and is actually the best time for both teachers and parents to establish a long lasting connection with the soon to be the belligerent full blown teenager.
The 10 to 12-year old’s behaviour is typically:
You may want to order yourself a copy of Louise Bates Ames, Frances L. llg and Sidney M Baker’s ‘Your Ten-to Fourteen-Year-Old’. They have presented their observation, consultation and discussion with parents. Loise Bates Ames is also the founder of Gesell Institute of Child Development. You may also want to read Gottman’s book ‘Raising an Emotionally Intelligent Child’.
With all the understanding – of your child’s circumstances and development — should you venture into measuring your pre-teen child’s academic performance.
What should be your method of measuring?
Then you also have to answer the following questions :
Academic performance is understood to be a measurable outcome of education, vis-à-vis the goals set by the student, teacher or institution and the parent. Most common measure of this achievement is by formative (continuous) assessment or summative (term end test/examinations) assessments. And it’s in this context that you need to argue and ask questions, some of which are listed above. There are no clear answers. Even within standardised tests administered to a class group in the same institution, it is argued whether procedural knowledge (skills and concepts) or declarative knowledge (information on content and facts) should be given more significance. IQ tests are scored by students with higher mental ability and is linked with effort and motivation for achievement in very academic environments. Whereas if your child is attending a school which is more flexible on curricular achievements and has plenty of co-curricular activities or even if your home learning environment is semi-structured, your child’s academic achievement would differ. You must factor in the discourse you have with your child on academic achievement, skill development and expectations of behaviour and attitude.
Another key factor that should be included as you measure your child’s academic performance would be your own academic socialisation. Your socio-economic status and that of your friends and family. Research has shown that the quality of relationship that you have with your child will influence the self-efficacy of your child and thus the academic achievement. Do measure your own quality time spent with your child, while judging your child’s academic performance.
Some of the practical ways to judge your child’s academic performance are:
According to studies conducted by Broh, 2002; Mahoney, Larson, Ecce, and Lord, 2005, participation in extracurricular activities have a positive influence on academic performance. Theatre rehearsal, soccer practice, piano lessons – all contribute towards academic achievement. So, when measuring your child’s academic performance, check out how the child is performing/engaging in the co-curricular activities and check if the graph is positive and indicating growth over time. Positive social relationships and behaviour, developing self-esteem, sense of citizenship – all of these are key markers to keep in mind, while measuring your child’s performance.
One of the areas I have spent most time as a K-12 educator are in discussions with parents to understand the changes that their child goes through at various ages. The ages of 10 to 12, as I have mentioned earlier in this article, are the early adolescent ones. They are not children; they are not young adults. The milestones are not as clearly defined as they are in the preschoolers or early primary years. The boys and girls go through many physical changes and not all of it begins or proceeds at the same pace. Along with the physical changes come the cognitive changes. These are less visible but are palpable to an involved parent. During this time, most of the children learn to think, reason and learn. They are able to conceive of ideas and projects in abstraction. They do not need to see or touch them to plan a project with the materials. They also want to experiment with reasoning and consequences. They can understand complicated emotions like for e.g. the fact that you can hide your sadness with a smile on your face. Your child can start anticipating how you will react to something he/she will say or do and is prepared with an explanation or an excuse or even fabricate a cover up story. As a parent, it is expected of you to be more open, show your trust, be less judgmental in your words as well as show it in your actions. It is important that your child should think it alright to tell the truth to you no matter what has happened.
During these years, it is best that you come to terms with the fact that your child is starting to think with more cognitive maturity, which is almost adult-like, even without having gone through the experiences of adulthood. The mental changes that your child is undergoing, is part of the process of ‘identity formation’. During these years, you will feel that your child is going through phases. It is important for them to go through this and struggle through their understanding of self – as a daughter/son, as a friend, as a class mate, as a student, as a team mate, as a sibling etc. These help them to handle their negative emotions like fear, sadness and anxiety in future. You might observe some contradictory habits like taking a long shower while participating in a marathon for a saving water campaign. He/she may spend hours texting with their friends only to criticize a peer for gossip.
You may want to check out some of the following links for further understanding of early adolescence.
http://www.hunter.cuny.edu/socwork/nrcfcpp/pass/learning-circles/four/Early%20adolescence.pdf
http://www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/childdevelopment/positiveparenting/middle2.html
While you are making an effort to understand your child, make yourself better understood by your child as well. How well does your child know you? Find out with this quiz. Make up some more questions and substitute mummy/daddy as applicable. This might encourage your child to make one on themselves as a result of which you will have known some more about your own child!
Here are 20 questions on you for your child (be prepared for the most unexpectedly honest answers that your child might come up with):
It would take you time to understand your pre-adolescent child and then some more to understand your adolescent child in years to come. As an educator and a parent, my advice would be to have patience, spend time to sit and chat without agenda, listen more – advise less, share more – ask less, understand more – judge less. As for academic performance – discuss more – measure less.
Nivedita Mukerjee is a journalist and an educator. She enjoys travelling and writes about travel and education with equal passion. She can be reached at niveditamukerjee10@gmail.com.
A version of this post has also been published here:
https://www.parentcircle.com/article/how-to-measure-your-preteens-academic-performance/
What should you consider before enrolling your child into IIT coaching? The question triggers thoughts in many directions. Is my child interested? Is my child capable? Where can I enrol him/her? Which is the best? What should I look for when I am choosing an institute? Do I send my child out of town? Can my child manage class 11 and 12 along with this preparation? Can after-school tuition replace coaching? Can the child prepare on his/her own? Can I afford it? Is it worth it? What should I do now?
Just for your information, these exams are conducted by the CBSE board. The NCERT books are heavily recommended for the preparation of both JEE (Engineering entrance) and NEET (medical entrance). You may want to keep this in consideration as your child enters the middle school years, if your child wants to consider working towards these entrance examinations over the years. Most definitely in the years of class 9 to 12.
I asked four of my friends what they had to say about their experience of putting their children through the fabled IIT entrance exam.
What they had to say:
Some parents mention that it is imperative to check references with families of ex-students for authenticating the institute’s claims. Institutes are notorious for paying toppers and other entrants with no connection to the institute to be able to put their name up on their marketing collaterals, hoardings etc. to enhance their saleability.
Most established coaching institutes offer a variety of courses.
Courses can be of the following configurations:
Seems like a lot of trouble. Do I even need an institute?
Coaching comes with a price, and no student loans are available for it. For most, this is a serious amount of money. Given the immense demand, coaching classes are “one-size-fits-all”. Teachers cannot attend to each student individually. Ultimately, it is the child who needs to put in the effort.
Cracking the IIT entrance exam is a dream for many students and their parents. It is arguably one of the world’s toughest exams. Can it be cracked without coaching? Many do just that: just about half of all entrants, in fact. Nonetheless, coaching is useful if you child needs additional motivation to revise, practice and keep to a schedule.
There are some clear advantages to coaching.
There are several well-known institutes:
http://www.embibe.com/100marks/jee-main-and-advanced-list-of-best-coaching-institutes/
https://www.toppr.com/bytes/top-10-coaching-institutes/
http://www.indiaeducation.net/top_colleges/coaching/engineering.aspx
http://www.kshitij-iitjee.com/blog/jee-coaching-institutes-in-india-with-remarkable-records
Which is the best? The answer is, simply, the one that most suits your needs.
Here are some pointers to help finalise the one for you:
Additionally, look for:
Once enrolled
Ensure the wellbeing of your child. Discuss what is important. You want the best for the child. Success will be neither achieved nor enjoyed if it comes at the cost of emotional or physical comfort.
Some tips from a school psychologist for aspirants:
Your child will be under a lot of pressure, self-induced, or brought on by their teachers, society, peers, and family. According to Vinita Shah, a career counsellor for the last 13 years, all those around the child should know how to handle this pressure with understanding. Pressure, poorly tackled, can have a lasting negative impact on all concerned. The expectations and dynamics of the whole system surrounding the child should be managed in a balanced manner.
In conclusion:
Granted, getting into IIT is a dream for many, but not getting through should not be regarded as evidence of failure or ineptitude for either child or parent. Such negative thinking impacts self-esteem. IIT is not equal to success. What is success? For parents and children, these are enlightening discussions to be had.
Our adolescents need career counselling, not mere guidance. Emotional support and a rational decision-making process are both essential. A child should be constantly supported through this acute and arduous journey.
According to Prof. Ashok Mishra, ( ex-IITian himself, Ex Dean of IIT Bombay (2004-2008), currently chairman of JEE main and chairperson BoG IIT Roorkee), coaching institutes are serving a purpose of building competency and filling up the lacunae created by inadequacies of the school system. It’s a business borne out of incompetency of the primary service – that of schools. In the report to MHRD on the JEE system, the committee headed by him has made several recommendations. Here’s the link to the complete report:
An excerpt from the report:
The current coaching is a very lucrative ‘industry’. As mentioned earlier, it has revenues of approximately Rs. 24,000 crores per year. However, it seems to fill a void – the absence of good teaching in schools – and does it effectively enough to make lots of money also. It is not always mindless profit, indeed at least some of the Coaching Institutions offer ‘scholarships’ for bright students who can’t afford them otherwise. There are still three objections. · The first is philosophical (yet important). The purpose of education is refinement of the mind not passing an entrance examination. · The second concerns the fact that ‘all work and no play’ makes a plus 12 grade student a dull individual with less involvement in activities other than studies. · The third is that students are forced to waste a lot time commuting in order to avail the benefit of ‘good’ coaching.
As an educator, parent and writer, I think and write about the wellbeing of school age children. Do share your views on this post and follow my blog for more if this space interests you.
A version of this article has been published here https://www.parentcircle.com/article/iit-entrance-coaching-points-to-ponder/

Dear fellow educators,
14th November was introduced in our country to celebrate and emphasize the importance of children in society and nation building. Happy Children’s Day! It’s time to let them play.
In my years of training, learning and working as an educator, I have heard and read very often: Let the children play. Teach them to be happy. Teach them to respect themselves and others. Give them time to be friends and socialize. To grow as human beings. I believe that all of us as parents and educators, wish to provide for these in our children’s lives. Yet, what is it that we do by design to make time for their leisure during the most crucial years of their journey? How does the ecosystem of school, home and society work towards providing this time for play? Let’s do the math for the hours in a day in the life of a school student. Give or take some minutes, this is what it typically looks like.
This makes for a gruelling 13 to 15-hour day for a K-12 student. Week after week. On Weekends, there is often make-up class in school, weekend homework or additional prep for test/exam that would be coming up in the following week. On an average, a student spends one to 3 hours a day on homework and school related assignments. Homework has entered into our teaching/parenting conversations… don’t forget your homework tomorrow or else… says the teacher. Do your homework before you go out to play… says the parent. Over the last 100 years, homework has become entrenched in a student’s life.
At one time, rather than diagnosing children with various attention deficit disorders, paediatricians would prescribe more outdoor exercise. I remember, during the time my grandmother was a head mistress in a primary school, she would often come home and talk about how she sent the fidgety ones out running in the school grounds in between the periods! There were discussions on elimination of homework and periodicity of tests for all students under 15 as it stressed them. That was the age when they would go for Matriculation exam – as 10th Grade exit. This is for the years before Intermediate college/ PUC or 11th/12thin school. The cold war made the crisis of homework deeper with assumption that Russian children were smarter, working harder and achieving more in the school. The opinion which was swinging away from homework, swung back and abolishing or limiting homework thought process was overturned. Over the years, homework was looked at taking over outdoor play, creativity and over all social development.
The National Education Association issued this statement in 1966:
It is generally recommended (a) that children in the early elementary school have no homework specifically assigned by the teacher; (b) that limited amounts of homework—not more than an hour a day—be introduced during the upper elementary school and junior high years; (c) that homework be limited to four nights a week; and (d) that in secondary school no more than one and a half hours a night be expected. (In Wildman, 1968, p. 204)
However, through the years, the swing continued on thoughts of what was to be considered good homework and what was bad homework; what was good enough at what age and so forth. For more on the beliefs, moralistic views, puritan work ethic, behaviourism and the cultural stress on performance, here’s a link to an article.
http://www.ascd.org/publications/books/108071/chapters/The-Cult(ure)-of-Homework.aspx
Here’s a list that I tweeted a couple of weeks ago of what possibilities open up when homework does not call dibs on the student’s time.
nivedita mukerjee @nmukerjee1 Oct 26
31 Things Your Kids Should Be Doing Instead of Homework http://www.parent.co/31-things-your-kids-should-be-doing-instead-of-homework/?utm_source=sumome&utm_medium=twitter&utm_campaign=sumome_share …
There’s no arguing that all children need play time, down time and family time. However most of that is taken up by homework time! on weekdays and weekends. What do the best in education system – the Finnish schools have to say about this?
Click on this link for a glimpse into that:
Here’s your 20 question quiz on what you think Homework is. Say True or False.
As an educator when you plan a homework assignment, what is your objective? How much time should they need to spend on the homework? Do you share that expectation with your students? How much homework is just the right amount for a particular grade? When does it stop being meaningful? The 10-minute rule, which calls for 10 minutes of homework per day per grade is endorsed by some schools. You may want to think about yours.
Yours truly,
Nivedita Mukerjee
A fourth generation educator, aspiring to visit schools in Finland and wishes that teachers and parents question themselves and their school’s policy on homework.

Choosing the best preschool: how does one do it? This is the biggest question when the time comes to let your child out of your own care.
Over the last several years, I have personally met thousands of parents on this journey. I have had the privilege of understanding their needs and concerns and discussing suitable preschool choices. November is when most schools begin their admissions process for the next academic session. Announcements are made on the school’s website, on various digital platforms, news paper advertisements, pamphlets, hoardings, or to parents directly by sending out mailers and word of mouth. Additionally, some schools process admissions year-round and enroll students when seats become available.
What should you consider when choosing a preschool? First, you must ask yourself: what do I want for my child? How do I picture my child in a few years? Away from home, in a new environment and with unfamiliar adults, the little one starts a journey of learning and independence. This time of life should be filled with love, laughter and joy. Here is a list of considerations to keep in mind as you venture in search of the best preschool.
Tap into your network. Ask around to form your opinion. What do other parents in your neighborhood, extended family, and workplace know about the preschools their children went to or are currently attending? Record these impressions against the shortlist of preschools you are considering.
Develop an understanding of early childhood care. What makes these years so important in your child’s life? How does ECCE (Early Childhood Care and Education) impact the cognitive development and the social/behavioral development of young children? To read about how various faculties of children are shaped by the environment in which they develop, you may refer to:
Evidence from the Effective Pre-school and Primary Education project
Edited by Kathy Sylva, Edward Melhuish, Pam Sammons, Iram Siraj-Blatchford and Brenda Taggart.
By Gunilla Dahlberg, Peter Moss, and Alan Pence
By Tina Bruce
Educators like Froebel, Montessori, and Steiner agreed that young children learn best when they are given responsibility. They do not need adults to inspire them. They are self-motivated. They also do not need extrinsic rewards. They enjoy experimenting and learning in the process of making errors and making choices while at play. When children initiate their own tasks, they take agency over their own learning. However, when a child is required to follow a task presented to him/her or is expected to do something by way of instruction, it becomes work. When does intervention in a child’s learning become interference? What is an appropriate level of support, cooperation, and encouragement by an adult, so that the child does not get frustrated and flounder? These are some of the issues that you need to be conscious of when seeking a learning environment for your child.
Visit, visit, visit. Most parents I have come across are intuitive about their child’s needs. Visit the preschools, meet the adults present in the environment and see if you can picture your child there.
Here is an information-gathering checklist for your visits:
Know and understand each philosophy, and ask which the school uses.
While choosing a preschool, keep in mind the kind of grade school (especially primary school years, grades 1 to 5) you would like your child to attend. These early years will shape the personality of your child.
If the preschool choice you have made has been that of an inquiry-based discovery curriculum, with choices and open-ended activities, then the grade school should support the same. If the choice has been a skill and practice-based curriculum and a structured environment, then the choice for the primary years could be along the same lines.
Middle and senior school choices can be different from the early and primary years as by then you will better understand your child’s needs. The child would have figured out his/her strengths and interests as well. The choice of school environment will therefore be a combination, in varying ratios, of a) structured/open; b) academic/co-curricular oriented; c) sports oriented d) creative arts oriented; e) competitive/collaborative; f) STEM/liberal arts oriented and so forth. How to choose the best grade school for your child? To answer this question requires a separate post, to follow soon.
The jury on parenting is always out. What defines best is debatable. Please share your thoughts and experiences with preschools as a reply to this post, and help other readers form their opinion and make the best choice for their children. I have left some of the questions raised in this post unanswered. Over time, I will share my professional opinion on these in my Ask Niv series.

‘TanaBana’ is Hindi for the ‘warp and weft’ of a weave. And that’s what it is: a story woven with the ‘Tana’ of ideas, and the ‘Bana’ of illustrations from everyday events in the life of a child. The idea of this series emerged during a conversation between a couple of friends who share the passion of story, of education and of small interactions that can make a meaningful impact on a growing child’s mind.
I can see a rainbow I can see a rainbow (Click to download PDF) is the first in this series. It is free to download on any device. We would love to hear your and your child’s feedback. Let us know what you liked, and what we can improve, be it narrative, or illustration, or how we’re distributing the book.
We hope you and your child enjoy reading as much as my friends and I have enjoyed weaving!
The PDF is a bit large (around 30MB), because it contains several beautiful, high-resolution illustrations that we couldn’t bear to shrink! So it may take a few minutes to download.